The 85% Failure Rate: Why Most New Brands Die in Retail (And the Audio Strategy That Saves Them)
Here's the brutal truth about launching a new brand in US retail: 85% fail within two years. That's not just a scary statistic; it's a $2 trillion graveyard of good products, innovative entrepreneurs, and wasted investment.
But here's what the surviving 15% know that others don't: Brand awareness isn't a luxury. It's the difference between life and death in retail. Full Stop.
What Brand Awareness Means (And Why It's Everything)
Before we delve into why brands fail, let's clarify what brand awareness entails. Brand awareness is a potential customer's ability to recognize and recall your brand when they need your product or service. It's not just knowing your name exists; it's the instant mental connection between your brand and the solution you provide.
Research defines brand awareness as "a potential customer's ability to know a brand and correctly connect it to its specific product or service." But here's the crucial part: brand awareness is the foundation for brand trust and loyalty. Studies consistently show that "consumers have higher purchase intention with a familiar brand," and high levels of brand awareness correspond directly to high market share.
Think about your shopping behavior. When you need pain relief, do you ask for "acetaminophen" or "Tylenol"? When you want a tissue, do you reach for "facial tissue" or "Kleenex"? That's brand awareness in action. And, it's worth billions.
The Real Reason Most Brands Fail: The Awareness Gap
Now let's talk about why brands actually fail. Nielsen's comprehensive research reveals the stark reality: of the consumer packaged goods that launch in the US today, only 15% will still exist in two years. Even worse, recent industry analysis confirms that nearly 95% of new products fail to meet their targets.
The failure rate is so consistent it's almost mathematical. Research by retail expert Inez Blackburn shows that while the top 20 US food companies have a 24% failure rate, the bottom 20,000 companies have an 88% failure rate. The key difference? "Apparent lack of research and strategic marketing done by the bottom 20,000."
Most emerging brands focus on the wrong problem. They obsess over product development, packaging design, and retail placement while ignoring the fundamental issue: Consumers won't buy what they don't know exists.
Nielsen's BASES research found that CPG innovations launched without adequate preparation showed an 80% failure rate. More telling: innovations with strong product performance were 15x more likely to succeed than those with poor performance—but only if consumers were aware of them.
Here's the brutal reality: Retailers stock products that consumers actively seek. When consumers recognize and trust a brand, they're more likely to purchase it. Without that recognition, even perfect products gather dust on shelves. Retailers need evidence that consumers will buy your product.
The Investment Trap: Why Digital-First Strategies Fail Many New Brands
Most emerging brands make a critical strategic error: They launch retail before building brand recognition.
The typical playbook looks like this:
Develop a product and secure retail placement
Launch digital advertising to drive awareness
Hope consumers discover the brand in-store
Wonder why sales velocity disappoints retailers
This backward approach results in wasted investment. In a typical digital campaign environment, it can take a year to reach the level of awareness necessary to increase retail sell-through significantly.
Here's what actually happens:
Digital ads reach people at home while the product is available in stores
Attribution is nearly impossible between digital exposure and in-store purchase
Consumers forget the brand by the time they're shopping
Retailers see poor sell-through and discontinue the product
Consumer behavior research shows that brand awareness "is the degree to which consumers can recognize and recall a brand," and this recognition builds the trust that drives purchase decisions. Without pre-existing awareness, even perfect in-store placement fails.
The Audio Advantage: Why Sound Builds Retail Success
Here's where innovative brands separate themselves from the 85% failure rate: Audio advertising creates the brand awareness that makes retail placement successful.
The Reach Reality: Audio advertising reaches 91% of U.S. adults weekly, surpassing any other digital platform. For emerging brands that need maximum awareness quickly, this reach is invaluable.
The Trust Factor: Research demonstrates that audio is "the most trustworthy among other media sources" and generates "more emotional activation and engagement than other media forms."
Why Retailers Prefer Audio-Aware Brands
Savvy retailers understand that brands with pre-existing consumer awareness perform better on shelves. When a buyer sees evidence that consumers are already searching for a brand, placement becomes strategic rather than speculative. This is why brand awareness isn't just a marketing metric: it's a retail imperative.
Building an Audio campaign into your retail launch plan shows retail buyers that you:
Are planning to support the retail placement with advertising geared towards increasing brand awareness and driving traffic to the retailer
Research confirms that "brand awareness plays an important role in consumer decision-making, market performance, marketing mix, and brand equity." Retailers want brands that consumers actively seek, not products they need to convince consumers to try.
The Competitive Advantage: Acting While Others Fail
Here's the opportunity: While 85% of new brands follow a failing playbook, the audio-first approach remains underutilized.
Most emerging brands still view audio as traditional radio, with limited targeting and unclear attribution. They don't realize that modern audio advertising offers:
Precision targeting based on demographics, interests, and behaviors
Digital-level attribution through pixels and promo codes
Cost efficiency compared to video production and digital CPMs
Immediate reach without algorithm learning phases
The brands that understand this advantage are capturing market share while their competitors struggle with the traditional approach.
Your Next Move: Break the Failure Cycle
The 85% failure rate isn't inevitable. It's the result of avoidable strategic mistakes. The surviving 15% understand that retail success requires consumer awareness first, not retail placement first.
Audio advertising solves the fundamental challenge: How do you build brand awareness before you have retail distribution?
The answer changes everything about how emerging brands approach market entry. Instead of hoping retailers will stock unknown products and consumers will discover them, you create consumer demand that makes retailers eager to carry your brand.
The window for this advantage won't stay open forever. As more brands adopt the audio-first approach, the competitive landscape will shift. The question is: Will you be among the 15% that survive, or the 85% that become a cautionary tale?
Ready to beat the 85% failure rate with a strategic approach to brand awareness? At Retail + Response, we've spent over 30 years helping emerging brands navigate the treacherous path from product development to retail success. We understand that having a great product isn't enough—you need consumer awareness that drives retail performance.
Our audio-first approach combines the reach and trust-building power of traditional media with modern measurement and optimization techniques. We help brands build the consumer awareness that makes retailers eager to stock their products, not just willing to test them.
Whether you're preparing for your first retail launch or looking to improve existing retail performance, our strategic expertise in both audio advertising and retail dynamics can help you avoid the common mistakes that can harm emerging brands.
Schedule a strategy session to discover how the correct brand awareness strategy can transform your retail prospects.
External Sources: